by Marbles_00 on Sun Mar 19, 2006 6:24 am
I can understand your frustration. Windows XP machines can be a real pain to connect to, but it sounds as though it is some permissions setting on the server machine, and nothing really to do with any of your setup, or even with Xlobby.
This reminds me once when I tried to hook my brother's and dad's computers together a couple of months ago so they could share an internet connection. Both running XP, I could see both computers on the network, yet I couldn't get them to communicate, share files or access the internet from one through the other (using Winroute). I don't recall exactly what the setting was, but is was down in the network settings of the one XP machine.
After that, it was another reason for me not to upgrade to WinXP and just keep my Win2000 machines running.
As it sounds like it is totally something to do with the server machine, I would look very intently at its permissions and network settings almost scrutinze every setting and compare it to the third pc which appeared to work okay.